Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy
Yesterday, workers began dismantling the 7-Eleven on the SE corner of Avenue A and 11th Street, including painting over the wraparound sign.
As expected, the store officially closed after 11 years in business.
I spoke with Mr. Singh, who bought the business from the previous owner seven years ago. He was emotional but optimistic about the store's closure. He declined to have photos taken but spoke a bit about his life, his philosophy and faith, and the now-shuttered franchise he licensed on Avenue A.
Singh, 50, and his wife and kids live in Queens after immigrating from India in the early 2000s. He credits his strong Sikh faith with keeping him optimistic about the future.
He used to work the overnight shift at Punjabi Deli on Houston Street to save money to buy the franchise. He spoke movingly about his history working his father's land in India by hand, taking care of his family as a breadwinner from his teenage years until now.
When I asked him why the store was closing, he reiterated what I'd heard on my last visit: rampant theft.
He explained that he is responsible for paying for everything that happens in the store. For example, when two armed robbers stole most of his cigarette packs, he was responsible for the $17 or $18 per pack. He still had to pay the distributor when people shoplifted six-packs of beer.
While the 7-Eleven parent company covers the store's rent, he pays 51% of every dollar he makes to the parent company. He also rents 7-Eleven machines from them. The Slurpee machine, he said, costs $700 per month to rent, and he has three of them. And when they broke, he had to pay for repairs. He also had to pay payroll, which he said was a high cost for two employees per shift.
He mentions daily shoplifting by kids from a nearby school, plus people who just saunter in, take what they please, and walk out. He said he is not allowed to stop them, and even if his cashier were to run after them and take the purloined items back, they'd be leaving the register unattended to do so.
They called the police occasionally, though the thieves were always long gone when the officers arrived.
I asked him what he plans to do next. Singh said he might look at another space in Queens near where he lives. He says he doesn't have ill will or bad feelings toward people and credits his faith in God and the holy book to the fact that things will be alright.
He thanked all the customers who visited the shop over the past seven years and wished everyone well in the future.
As I was leaving, the third-party contractors were putting paper up on the windows, and we watched them for a minute.
Singh looked at me and said, "I am not afraid of hard work. I have been a hard worker my whole life. God will protect me, and I am not sad."
This is the third 7-Eleven to close in the East Village since 2013. The last one, on the Bowery, will be shutting down next. Look for that post tomorrow.
I don't understand how we got to NOT holding criminals and shoplifters accountable for their crimes. It cripples hard working business owners as in this case and makes the city unsafe. This business now has shut down (among many others). Its employees lost their jobs and the city looses tax revenue - both from the business and real estate taxes (as rental income is a component in determining real estate taxes).
ReplyDeleteI think we should be about 10,000x more interested in prevention than in holding people accountable. Speaking as the victim of a crime here.
DeleteThe pandemic's worst damage may be past us however it seems to have forever changed our society perhaps for decades to come. It is a tangled mess which the BLM and Defund the Police "movements" although seemingly logical where actually too abstract for the real world. A weird sense on entitlement has not gotten the best of us as corporate stores are now the dominate retail in NYC. Everyone wants to screw the CEO's but not everyone realizes that stealing from a store owner as this one, directly impact this man and his family.
ReplyDeleteGlad to see it go.
ReplyDeletePart of the reason is homeless holding the front door begging for money all day.
Boycott places that management allows this rude behavior.
Defund the police was seized upon by the GOP but has absolutely nothing to do with funding social workers and mental health professionals to do the work police were never trained for. CEOs troughing off golden parachutes so the sucker also known as the franchisee takes the hit as well as the neighborhood that lost its mom and pop store for the wildly inflated rent. Well I certainly feel for this man, it is 7-Eleven that has created the fish in a barrel situation that prevents the store owner from enforcing the law in his own store. Now I do understand how 7-Eleven wants to indemnify itself from everything under the sun, making this guy take a hit like this should give you pause and encouragement to find the mom and pop store to spend your money in.
ReplyDeleteHopefully, now the criminals lover's are out of the white house and the congress, President Trump will restore law and order and hold criminals responsible, and give back the police all the support they need to do their job.
ReplyDeleteYes, let's count on the convicted felon to restore law and order. Yikes.
DeleteBring back the old school ways of Law and Order! Society became too politically correct, too sensitive.
ReplyDeleteWe need a mayor who will fight for what's morally right! Adams never gave a shit about the city's well being.
I knew it back then. That's why I never voted for him. I can't stand self-righteous people.
Shoplifting has gotten out of control in NYC. The problem stems from these terrible criminal justice reforms and cashless bail or no bail for repeat offenders who just get summonses by the NYPD and don't bother to appear for their court dates, and nothing seems to happen to them. It is one of the main reasons why I voted for Trump people are just fed up.
ReplyDeleteThis is not a studied opinion, but it is one I've been unable to escape for years: police departments aren't significantly interested in *preventing* crime.
ReplyDeleteWhat? Do you suggest cops should employ a physic reader and adviser to help prevent crimes? The police are here to address a crime which has happened not one which may happen. Does stop and frisk seem like a good solution to you? Unfortunately more security guards might be needed to hold back the tide, can't see any way around that.
DeleteMaybe it's just that the rents are too damn high?
ReplyDeleteTheft is wrong and hurts everybody who is not stealing. But why do you all think a convicted felon in the White House will help with that?
ReplyDeleteGood point!
DeleteOr maybe the kids see a grifter as president and think, well, if he steals, so can I. Same with Adams. Our leaders are not setting good examples.
ReplyDeleteWell put and spot on!
DeleteIt's an age of scams and grifts. Vacuous platitudes vs authoritarian blarney at the top. Condescending moralizing and incompetent corruption locally. Bitcoin, rich kid influencers, con artists and ideological bullies are not good roll models but that's what we've got. Why would cops bother to crack down on shoplifting when multiple hate crimes just end up being lots of paperwork for them and a desk appointment ticket or maybe a court date for obvious criminals? A foot chase after a junior high school crew stealing candy bars?
ReplyDeleteI didn't like that 7/11, the whole franchise is too car park America for me, but the employees were nice the few times I dealt with them. The shuttered storefront count in the neighborhood seems to be growing. Graffitied gates boarded windows are signs of the times.
Clampdown has already started. Farebeaters are being stopped and ticketed. Hired security guards are preventing people from going thru the gated doors. For the first time I noticed a massive police presence on Canal/ Broadway last week impounding all the counterfeit junk that was being sold.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand 7-11s sell basically the worst possible shit you could put into a human body- High levels of salt, sugar, high fructose corn syrup, preservatives, chemicals and nicotine causing just about every preventable disease there is. Sorry, not sorry. Bye.
I call it trickle-down crime. If criminals are running things, I do think people are fed up enough to not take seriously our system of laws; however, the promised extremist response of "Let's shoot shoplifters on site," apropos of the incoming administration, I really think retail will also take a hit on that. You can count on online shopping forever if we ever have to witness people getting shot for petty theft. But I agree, the system in place is allowing shoplifting beyond what I ever imagined. And it pisses off those of us who still pay for stuff. But chaos is the desire of the disruptors, right?
ReplyDeleteSigh... I remember when this place was the lovely dive bar with occasional live music, Bar On A.
ReplyDeleteAs said in this substack (https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-blue-cities-must-be-fixed), it's not hard to see why people would lean right when the blue cities like NYC and SF can't even govern themselves. This is just one of many examples of failure and every New Yorker, regardless of politically slant, should feel angry about the state of things.
ReplyDeleteThe LES , always a place for immigrants. Many worked hard, raised their families and hoped for the American dream. I feel very sorry for this hard working man.
ReplyDeleteThe LES can also be very dangerous. Unfortunately, criminals don’t care about how hard you are working for your dream.
Wasn't there supposed to be a Japanese version of 7-11 in lieu of this?
ReplyDeleteIt’s a corporate decision to close not the person interviewed. This guy still made money to the end. He was just a general manage of the location. Theft cut into his profits a bit but he still made money. Everything in there is tremendously marked up. Corporate decided it’s not worth it because profits are down and they are the ones paying rent. They mark everything up many times over cost so don’t feel too bad for them. This was the business model for this location. Vagrancy and theft is a different problem. City will not do anything about it.
ReplyDeleteStores like this would be better served to put everything into large vending machines with touch screens to read labels etc if needed. Do away with cashiers and unsecured goods. There is no reason any goods need to be out on shelves
ReplyDeleteThank you for your input citizen. Please report to processing and may the odds ever be in your favor.
DeleteI like that idea.
Delete