Tuesday, November 17, 2026

After 17 sweet years, the St. Nicholas Cookie Walk comes to an end

Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy

After 17 years of homemade cookies and holiday cheer, the St. Nicholas Cookie Walk will not return this Christmas. 

St. Nicholas of Myra Orthodox Church has announced the end of the popular East Village holiday tradition, which grew from a modest bake sale into an annual event featuring dozens of homemade cookies from the church basement at Avenue A and 10th Street.
"We know this news will be disappointing to the many families, friends, and visitors who have made the Cookie Walk part of their Christmas traditions," organizers said in their announcement. 

The Cookie Walk began 17 years ago during a snowstorm, recalled the Rev. Father William Bennett, pastor of St. Nicholas.

"Such a little bake sale in a very small room, but with a little hope," he said.
Word spread largely through neighborhood connections, a sign outside the church and coverage on EVG. 

"We seemed to have what the people were looking for, for the season," Father William said. "A little joy, some cookies, a little fun. And it really took off." 

Much of that success was due to longtime organizer Kim Busel, whose dedication helped transform the event into a neighborhood favorite. 

By the parish's centennial celebration in 2025, the Cookie Walk had grown to offer 100 varieties of cookies. But the event's popularity also made it increasingly difficult to organize and sustain. 

"It's such a big thing and such a beautiful thing that it's difficult for anybody to fathom taking on," Father William said. "And that's the gap. That's why it's come to a close as it is." 

For Busel, the decision was particularly difficult. "Right now, I would be in the middle of flour, sugar and butter," she told EVG. "And I would be so happy to be there." 

She had hoped to organize one more Cookie Walk, but ongoing health issues made that impossible this year. 

"Last year, I wasn't willing to say that it was the last Cookie Walk. I felt like I still had one more left in me," she said. "Unfortunately, as this year progressed, my health kept reminding me that I needed to tend to it first before I could even think of making my first cookie." 

Busel (below right) has surgeries scheduled for January and May and hopes to return to holiday festivities once she has recovered.
The Cookie Walk also became known for its hot chocolate, another detail Busel took seriously. Each year, her household prepares chocolate from a different country. This year's selection is Switzerland. She had even dreamed of expanding the event's hot chocolate bar.

"I have always wanted to expand the hot chocolate bar to something extraordinary," she said. While the Cookie Walk itself has come to an end, there may be another holiday celebration in the church's future. 

Father William said he has begun discussing the possibility of organizing something similar next year, although no formal plans have been made. 

Busel also hopes a new group of organizers might eventually take the lead. "The hope is that we can resume a holiday celebration again with new people at the helm," she said. 

For now, both are reflecting on the friendships and memories created over nearly two decades.

"We have met so many East Village neighbors over the years, who now feel like friends," Busel said. "I know it is a disappointment for 2026. We feel it as well."

1 comment:

  1. Cheers to Ms. Busel and the church for creating such a wonderful tradition! Thank you for the memories, the Cookie Walk became an endearing holiday tradition and it will be dearly missed. Hopefully someone else can pick up the mantle to keep the tradition going, I can't fathom how much work it must be.

    ReplyDelete

Your remarks and lively debates are welcome, whether supportive or critical of the views herein. Your articulate, well-informed remarks that are relevant to an article are welcome.

However, commentary that is intended to "flame" or attack, that contains violence, racist comments and potential libel will not be published. Facts are helpful.

If you'd like to make personal attacks and libelous claims against people and businesses, then you may do so on your own social media accounts. Also, comments predicting when a new business will close ("I give it six weeks") will not be approved.