Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy
The collection of small bronze sculptures that mysteriously appeared throughout Tompkins Square Park — and became a source of curiosity and delight for parkgoers — is disappearing.
On Friday morning, EVG reader Jill Woodward alerted us that she had spotted a Parks Department employee removing some of the artwork. Woodward initially thought the employee was photographing the sculptures. Then she noticed a chisel and other removal tools.
When Woodward asked whether the pieces were being removed, and why, the employee reportedly replied, "Unfortunately, yes, because rules are rules."
By the time we arrived, many of the bronze pieces had already been removed, including some favorites: the crushed can, the pizza and plate, the syringes and baggies, and the stepped-in dog poop.
A Parks source, not authorized to speak on the record, said a team visited Tompkins last Thursday to inspect the installations. On Friday morning, the department's monuments team arrived to remove them.
The reason, according to the source, was straightforward: The sculptures had been installed in the park without permission.
The tiny bronze objects, many attached to the pavement or other surfaces, had been appearing around Tompkins over the past two years. They depicted everyday items — cigarette butts, bottle caps, food wrappers and other bits of urban litter — transformed into permanent-looking fixtures.
Their discovery prompted our ongoing series documenting the pieces and the people behind them.
We had been preparing a fourth installment featuring an interview with the bronze caster who helped create many of the sculptures.
He spoke at length about the effort involved in making the installations last.
"I've always been really deep into bronze casting," he told us. "When you cast stuff in metal and you impregnate it in the stone, there's a level of permanence that comes with that."
He continued: "We didn't want it where you could just put a solvent on it and then you could pull it up. I came up with the way to attach these to the ground where they would be practically impossible to rip up. It would increase the survivability of any one of the sculptures."
The goal, he said, was "to spark that sense of imagination and curiosity."
We have since spoken with both the artist and the bronze caster. Neither has ruled out creating more work locally, though there are no concrete plans at the moment.
For now, the sculptures that turned ordinary bits of sidewalk litter into something worth stopping to examine are largely gone.
Fortunately, we've documented many of them over the past several weeks.
Here's a look back at the tiny treasures of Tompkins Square Park...
Previously on EV Grieve:Slideshow of some of the Tompkins Treasures, bronze works of everyday art hidden in the park https://t.co/CXQEdAE3js
— Stacie Joy (@Joy_of_photos) November 14, 2026






15 comments:
Unfortunately, I knew this was going to happen as soon as this story was published 😕.
This really sucks. No offense Grieve, I love your work - but I really wish you had kept quiet about these. I knew this was going to happen if the sculptures got any publicity.
same here ... what a shame...
yes indeed, rules are rules, and government jerks are government jerks. Thanks, Parks Dept vandals, for making everyone's day just a little bit worse.
Cool art idea but I assume the bronze pieces were removed do to being a potential liability, i.e., a tripping hazard for example which of course they are depending on their placement.There is a reason there are rules, regulations and permits. People trip, buildings topple. Especially in NY people go fucking nuts if they think they can get away with something.
Don’t be surprised if one of the Parks Department employees swipes these and sells them on eBay. A similar thing happened at last year’s election when the Knicks won. Board Of Elections had a special commemorative I Voted Early sticker just for one day and someone working at BOE stole some and BOE saw them for sale on eBay the same day
Didn't they say they were considering how/whether to extend the installations outside the confines of the park itself? Certainly there is precedence with the tiles, the orange line, etc. Parks should make an effort to return the items.
What a pity. Don’t blame Grieve tho!
They shared this little bit of magic with us when we might never have discovered it. My son and I had a very fun afternoon hunting around and luckily snapped pics of our finds.
It was never going to last forever! It wasn’t intended to.
I agree, don't blame Grieve! This was like the Schrodinger's Cat of art installations. If Grieve never published the story, the art would not have been noticed by most of the people reading this comment. By publishing the story, them art was removed by the parks department and now no one can see it. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. It was certainly fun while it lasted!
Sure we can do something about this. We’re the East Village! These type of actions are what has defined us for decades. What about collecting signatures to contest Parks action? Requesting the sculptures to be given back and to stop them fron removing the others? Or an in-person gathering at the park? Let’s protect this artists’ work, it’s our heritage!
Can't say I agree. The sculptures have been there for a while for anyone who bothers to pay attention to their surroundings. They get publicized and posted on social media for the gentrifiers and their kids to go on easter egg hunts and now nobody gets to enjoy them.
Next, the city will remove Jim Powers’ mosaic artwork from the hood. Governmental priorities usually tend to suck
I think we must embrace the impermanence, the ephemeral nature of this sort of art installation. It was here for a time and we got a chance to enjoy it. Now it is in another phase of its existence. Perhaps more works will be made and strewn across the park. Those too may be removed by the parks department because ‘rules are rules’ But for a while, we broke the rules, and that was fun.
This city can be incredibly stupid.
"virtually impossible to remove"... Lol I guess not. This falls under the "everybody's got a plan until they get punched in the face" category. I had thought a masonry chisel and hammer would make quick work of removing them. Also concrete expands and contracts in hot to cold temperatures making removal of such small pieces very easy. Nature has a say too.
EV is a small sample, but it seems there is a lot of enthusiasm for public art of this type. Large scale pieces are on regular display in Madison Square Pk why not do something similar in TSP?
Post a Comment