Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy
An item was noticeably missing when we stopped by the just-opened Cinnabon/Carvel combo shop at 430 E. 14th St. in February.
An inventory of the cakes fridge revealed favorites such as Fudgie the Whale — but no Cookie Puss!
On a return visit, we were happy to see Tomas (above) with a handmade Cookie Puss, a beloved Carvel creation that dates to the 1970s.
Per Carvel lore, this cake is a fictional space alien who hails from Planet Birthday, complete with cookie eyes and an ice cream cone for a nose. (Did you not drop acid as a 10 year old?)
The Cookie Puss, perfect for birthdays, retails for $37.99 in store and feeds approximately 10 people or one really stoned person.
The store manager, Pradip, says you can call to preorder or just come in and pick one up from the fridge.
