More about the new comedy club in the works for 44 Avenue A

Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy

As noted last week, the former Upright Citizens Brigade's UCBeast space on Avenue A and Third Street has a new suitor: Mark Rothman, founder of the Top Secret Comedy Club, a UK-based venue with multiple locations. 

I spotted Rothman, who was visiting from the UK last week, collecting signatures on Friday. He said he first became interested in the Avenue A spot last fall.

After nearly a year of negotiations, he signed the lease two weeks ago. If all goes well, he plans to open later this fall.

"This is a comedy-focused place," Rothman told me of Top Secret, perhaps sensing possible opposition to a full liquor license for the space. "It's not drink-led, it's ticket-led. We are not a drinking establishment, we're a comedy club. There is no two-drink minimum here. We don't have tables, we don't have service, and no waiters. The alcohol is ancillary to the comedy."

The setup will feature theater-style seating, all facing the stage. A small bar at the front of the house will serve drinks during the shows. Rothman noted they use a queuing system capable of processing 30 customers per minute, which he says will help prevent long lines at the entrance.

As for food: with no kitchen in the space, the menu will be limited to frozen pizza and light bar snacks. Rothman's longtime colleague and friend, Claire Grinis, is moving to New York to manage the venue. Programming will focus almost exclusively on stand-up comedy, with the occasional musical-comedy act. 

The new venture will be the latest chapter for a space with plenty of recent history. UCB ran UCBeast here from September 2011 to February 2019, shuttering after citing the "extreme costs" of operating. 

More recently, the gallery-performance space O'Flaherty's made the address its home, closing last year after a memorable 18-month run.

Rothman's application is on CB3's SLA Licensing & Outdoor Dining Committee agenda for tonight. The meeting is at 6:30, and the Zoom link is here. This is a hybrid meeting, with limited seating available for the public — the first 15 people who arrive at the Community Board 3 Office, 59 E. Fourth St., between Second Avenue and the Bowery.