Photos and article by Gemma Colón
Top photo via @postnewyork
What looked like a rescue mission turned out to be only a postponement. On Sunday, Post served its last brunch and closed for good, days short of its 10th anniversary.
For nearly a decade, the East Village spot was more a community hub than a traditional restaurant, though it was also an excellent one.
The back-and-forth
On July 20, Post told its followers on Instagram that it would be closing soon. The caption had one word: "Bye."
About a month later, on Aug. 21, a new post said, "prayers have been answered." Post was staying.
Then, two days before the final service on Nov. 15, a photo of Myki and Bobby Stackleather, the brothers who opened Post, went up with this caption:
"Well folks, that's a wrap!! Just days shy of our tenth anniversary, we're closing shop. Sunday brunch will be our last day of service. We want to thank everyone for their continued patronage, it never went unnoticed. We love you tons and hope to meet again soon."
Staff say the first announcement brought a wave of goodwill. It brought in customers, and it also brought in prospective buyers. The buyers pulled out of the purchase at the last minute, leaving Post no choice but to close on short notice.
10 years, 2 addresses
Myki and Bobby Stackleather opened Post at 42 Avenue B in November 2016. It started as a biscuit-centered breakfast café with coffee and tea, and lunch and dinner came later.
In the early days of the pandemic, the brothers stayed open for takeout and used their kitchen to cook for health-care workers, funded through a GoFundMe.
In 2021, Post moved around the corner to 217 E. Third St., between Avenue B and Avenue C, and reopened that July.
The new space had a backyard garden, and that changed everything.
The garden, the algorithm and the ebb and flow
The backyard came along at exactly the right moment. In the post-COVID, work-from-home era, New Yorkers wanted a place to be outside, sit for a while, and see other people.
Post's secret-garden patio, tucked behind a narrow dining room on Third Street, was that place. Videos of the garden went viral, and the brunch line grew to match.
One video can turn a neighborhood favorite into a destination overnight, often before the owners know it's happening. But virality doesn't guarantee stability. The crowds that come for a clip don’t always come back, and the people who keep a place running are the regulars.
Then social media turned the tide again. A one-word Instagram post from July filled the room, rallied the neighborhood, and drew in would-be buyers.
In the end, attention couldn’t change the outcome, but it did make sure Post went out the way it deserved: full.
The last day
On the final day, the three-top in front of me was quoted a 30- to 45-minute wait. As a solo diner, I waited 25 minutes for a seat at the bar.
The neighborhood turned out in droves again, this time to celebrate Post and say goodbye rather than to save it.
The brothers were hosting, seating, and serving guests themselves. The mood was celebratory, calm, and accepting.
"All good things must come to an end," one of them was overheard saying as he handed bottles of rosé to "favorite" customers.
As always, something about the space made people connect, both with the people next to you and with the staff. I've dined alone at Post many times and always felt comfortable.
Even on the last day, knowing none of us would be back, the diners on either side of me were chatty and warm. Post drew a crowd that wanted to connect, and over the years I've met people there who are still friends.
The menu
Post wasn’t fully vegan, but it was vegan-forward. Myki went vegan about 10 years ago, and that shaped the menu. Some dishes were fully plant-based, and the rest were built so vegans and non-vegans could eat well at the same table.
The menu also kept people who were moving toward a vegan diet in mind, to make that switch easier. Plenty of non-vegan regulars ordered entirely vegan meals without thinking twice. The vegan biscuit, which reportedly took two years to perfect, was a big reason why.
Then there was the rest: live jazz, happy hour, breakfast through dinner, the garden, a great staff, and locally sourced, organic, humanely raised food.
What’s next?
Will the brothers open another spot? It's unclear. We've been told to keep an eye out.
For now, we wish them some rest, and we hope they’re proud of what they built: a place that made neighbors into friends.




No comments:
Post a Comment