A 'cleanup only' operation on 11th Street and 1st Avenue

Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy 

What's happening at 11th Street and First Avenue? "Cleanup" is the word of the day.

Unlike the last cleanup — held at noon on one of the hottest days of the year — this one took place yesterday morning (Jan. 16) at 9 on one of the frostiest. It was 24 degrees, with a real-feel in the teens.

The new Mayor has been vocal about a shift at City Hall away from "sweeps." And unlike previous actions in the area, Friday's operation was being described as a cleanup at 11th Street and First Avenue — with no enforcement behind it, according to the NYPD.

Vincent Gragnani, press secretary for the NYC Department of Sanitation's Bureau of Public Affairs, described it as routine street and sidewalk cleaning.

"This was a standard street and sidewalk cleaning operation, at the request of NYPD, not a more involved joint operation," he said. "We were asked to clean litter in the area, as we routinely do at the request of agencies, elected officials, community complaints, etc, and that is exactly what we did."

As we've been reporting, the actions here follow a surge in community complaints about noise, congestion and food waste tied to the block's unofficial use as a waiting and staging area for e-bike delivery workers (aka deliveristas). The quality-of-life concerns have also come up regularly at recent 9th Precinct Community Council meetings.

"This is a cleanup on 11th Street based upon community complaints," a police source said. "We're not doing enforcement at this time."

The source said the plan was for deliveristas to move their bicycles to allow for the cleanup.

The NYPD said they would not be taking any bikes or bags, unlike previous actions in this area. 

"The goal is not to take anything. We're using outreach to spread the word." 

Will summonses be issued?

"Not unless we observe someone breaking the law," the source said. 

On-site Sanitation 

Sanitation workers on site said they were told the NYPD likely wouldn't be part of the morning's cleanup, citing "a change in plans."

A supervisor said the department was there to clean the area in response to complaints, using mechanical brooms, a motorized truck, and backpack blowers. Sanitation can typically reach the curbline, but the bike corral makes the area difficult to access.

"It's up to the NYPD if we take anything," the supervisor said. "We don't even have the tools to remove bike locks and chains. But if there's abandoned property that no one claims, we remove it."

Community Board 3 

CB3 District Manager Susan Stetzer said she made the cleanup signs and had them translated into multiple languages.

She was on site Friday morning, along with Tyler Hefferon, executive director of EV Loves NYC, several community members, and a representative from Councilmember Harvey Epstein's office.

Hefferon states he was given additional copies of the notice and asked to assist with outreach. 

"I was told this was a Department of Sanitation-led cleanup and that there would be no bike seizures like last time, but I encouraged people to treat this like alternate-side street parking, Hefferon said. "It did not seem as urgent as the last time, but local mutual aid groups plus Los Deliveristas Unidos helped me get the word out." 

Meanwhile, Stetzer struck a mix of optimism and frustration. She said the cleanup effort was discussed at the Community Board's monthly District Service Cabinet meeting, which she noted is required under the City Charter and brings together multiple city agencies focused on service delivery issues in the district.

When the proposed cleanup came up, she said Sanitation, the NYPD, the City Council, and DOT were in attendance and "participated in plans," adding, "This is why these meetings are so valuable and productive." She also noted that community construction liaisons for ongoing projects attend and provide status reports.

Stetzer said the Board is "very excited to work with the new mayor's office," but has "very frustratingly… not been able to do so at this time." She added that the city's Community Assistance Unit (CAU) "appears to have been disbanded but not replaced." 

She said she hopes the Mayor's office reaches out to community boards soon, "so that as city agencies we can work with them and request information and support."

As for the operation itself, Stetzer said she felt "the cleanup went well," emphasizing that "it was a cleanup, not a punitive action." She said the larger issue remains unresolved: "Parking a hundred bikes on this block is not sustainable," and simply adding more bike corrals — which she said can take a year to install — "is not a solution." 

She called it "a failure of government to plan and provide infrastructure," and said the community is hopeful the new administration will help resolve the situation.

Stetzer pointed to the role of delivery app companies, saying they are "making money on the work of the delivery workers without providing accommodation or benefits." She said the City needs both an infrastructure plan and legislation "that will hold companies responsible for bike storage and necessary accommodation for the workers." 

Without that, she said, complaints from residents can lead to enforcement actions where "punitive actions fall on the workers who have no means to comply."

She also noted that many delivery workers are "new Americans" and said that past bike confiscations required court appearances to retrieve the bikes — something that can put some workers at risk. Stetzer said the goal is a plan that supports delivery, improves working conditions, holds app companies accountable, and gives workers a realistic way to comply.

As for what comes next, both NYPD and Sanitation officials said they expect to continue responding to community complaints in the area, while everyone waits for a longer-term solution.

 

Previously on EV Grieve: 

• Deliveristas confront new hurdles after 11th Street bike sweep 

• Mass e-bike seizure sparks tensions and debate on 11th Street 

• Deliveristas face new enforcement in the East Village