The Benny's Burritos signage was removed from its one-time home (RIP 2014) on the SW corner of Sixth Street and Avenue A, a main hub during the several evenings of filming.
At times, it was hard to distinguish between the props for the shoot and the everyday randomness you'd expect to find along Avenue A.
Here's a quick guide to help determine what was a prop or not.
Bikes in a bunch: PROP Michigan football flag outside Offside on the NE corner of A and Sixth: NOT a prop Burgeoning sewer collapse on A and Sixth: NOT a propPigeons devouring the 50 pounds of bread someone dumps in the once-mucky tree pit: NOT a prop, obviouslyObey Giant wheat pastes on the side of Amor Y Amargo: PROPSCanopy left atop the M14 stop between Fifth Street and Sixth Street: NOT a propA sketchy-looking casting notice for a Young Zendaya: NOT a prop (and actually legit) Stop Warehousing Apartments Flyers: PROPSStack of school desks of the SE corner of A and Sixth: PROPS (sadly)Phone booth: PROPBikes locked up outside the Cherry Tavern: NOT SURE!Unhoused encampment on Sixth near A: PROP
Building-wide tags on the NW corner of Avenue A and Second Street: NOT props REVS COST tags on Sixth Street plus other tags: PROPSJesus Loves You ("Think About That") flyer: NOT a propRather hunky-looking guy dressed as if he could either be the building's porter or a serial entrepreneur who incubates and invests in breakthrough fintech companies: Guy, NOT a prop (though an actor); Car, PROP
Bikes in a bunch: PROP Michigan football flag outside Offside on the NE corner of A and Sixth: NOT a prop Burgeoning sewer collapse on A and Sixth: NOT a propPigeons devouring the 50 pounds of bread someone dumps in the once-mucky tree pit: NOT a prop, obviouslyObey Giant wheat pastes on the side of Amor Y Amargo: PROPSCanopy left atop the M14 stop between Fifth Street and Sixth Street: NOT a propA sketchy-looking casting notice for a Young Zendaya: NOT a prop (and actually legit) Stop Warehousing Apartments Flyers: PROPSStack of school desks of the SE corner of A and Sixth: PROPS (sadly)Phone booth: PROPBikes locked up outside the Cherry Tavern: NOT SURE!Unhoused encampment on Sixth near A: PROP
Building-wide tags on the NW corner of Avenue A and Second Street: NOT props REVS COST tags on Sixth Street plus other tags: PROPSJesus Loves You ("Think About That") flyer: NOT a propRather hunky-looking guy dressed as if he could either be the building's porter or a serial entrepreneur who incubates and invests in breakthrough fintech companies: Guy, NOT a prop (though an actor); Car, PROP
We haven't heard anything official... but we're guessing that we haven't seen the last of the "Caught Stealing" shoot. We've heard rumors (and seen evidence of) a Pyramid Club and Mars Bar redux.