Stuffed closes, and the owners promise 'a brand new, never seen before' ice cream concept

Photos by Steven

Stuffed Ice Cream closed on Oct. 27 at 139 First Ave. between St. Mark's Place and Ninth Street.

The shop arrived in 2017 and spawned a second location in Bensonhurst. 

However, ownership has plans for the space...

In a closure notice for patrons, there's news of a new concept called Surprise Scoop opening next month. It will be "a brand new, never seen before FUN & EXCITING ice cream concept."

Stuffed Ice Cream coming to 1st Avenue

A worker renovating 139 First Ave. told EVG correspondent Steven that an ice cream shop is opening here this summer between St. Mark's Place and Ninth Street.

Work permits for the address shows that the business name is Stuffed Ice Cream. There isn't any other information at the moment.

Curious location for this: The space is just one storefront away from Davey's Ice Cream, which has a strong following and an extensive menu featuring sundaes, milk shakes and homemade cookies.

The address was previously home to American Deli & Grocery, which closed after five months in business... and before that, Scarab Lounge, a hookah joint, held forth.