Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy
Lucy's officially begins a new era tomorrow at 135 Avenue A between St. Mark's Place and Ninth Street.
Lucy's, now owned by Golden Age Hospitality, underwent renovations in recent months. Golden Age Hospitality CEO Jon Neidich, who previously lived upstairs and was a big Lucy's fan, promised to maintain the bar's look and feel and the same neighborhood bar vibes. (The renovations mainly included soundproofing in the ceiling and ADA bathrooms.)
When the ownership change was presented to Community Board 3 last summer, Eater noted: "At least up until now, Neidich's businesses are just about the antithesis of Lucy's." A Times profile noted how he and Golden Age are swanking up millennial nightlife. (Who doesn't love a caviar-baked potato?)
This past Thursday night, the new Lucy's debuted during a private party that included friends and neighbors, Golden Age associates, and a reporter or two.
The place looks almost identical to the Lucy's you visited before closing in November 2023. (This EVG post will bring you up to date.)
I have to say the bar looks pretty much like I remembered it — only a bit spiffier. It has a new jukebox featuring bands from Outkast to the Rolling Stones, new speakers, and a fresh coat of paint.
Elsewhere, there is a new ADA-compliant restroom and a cleaned-up storage room (I did not get to go into the basement, but I was told it's an empty storage area now). A team of enthusiastic bartenders also makes some carefully crafted cocktails. However, there are no contraband bottles of you-take-the-first-shot 192-proof Spirytus behind the bar.
One item is missing: the well-worn poster for the 1997 teen drama Hurricane Streets, which filmed a scene in the bar. Neidich said a new one is on its way.
Overall, it looks as if Neidich tried carefully to recreate the Lucy's of his earlier days.
Around 9:30, Ludwika "Lucy" Mickevicius, who opened the bar here in 1987, arrived on the scene after an outing with The New York Times to a very warm welcome...
Golden Age has said that Lucy will still have a presence here — even bartending. (Playing it cool, she told me she'll "be at the bar when I'm available.")
"It's good. It's nice. This is new, and it costs a lot of money. It was time to make a change. Mine was very old," she said. "This is just so nice. I still love it."
And on her return to the bar to see so many people happy to see her?
"I am surviving a long time because people care about me, and then people from all over the world come in to say hi, and they remember me."
The best part for me, personally, was seeing Lucy smile. She put down the cane she now uses, sat at a table by the front door, and looked around the bar at everyone enjoying the opening night private party.
She put her hand over mine and said, "You look tired, Stacie. Go home. I am staying maybe a little bit longer."
It was after midnight when I walked out, and she was still going strong.
Starting tomorrow (March 4), Lucy's is open seven days a week from 5 p.m. to 4 a.m. You can follow Lucy's on Instagram here.
Starting tomorrow (March 4), Lucy's is open seven days a week from 5 p.m. to 4 a.m. You can follow Lucy's on Instagram here.
Previously on EV Grieve: