Thursday, February 19, 2026

Sunday is the last day for the Onion Tree Pizza Co. on 1st Avenue

Top photo by Stacie Joy from the spring of 2024

After nearly two years on the SE corner of First Avenue and 13th Street, the Onion Tree Pizza Co. will permanently close after service on Sunday. 

Chef Jay Jadeja and his wife Raquel Wolf-Jadeja, who have owned and operated several NYC restaurants in the past 20-plus years, also run The Onion Tree in Sea Cliff on Long Island's North Shore. That outpost will remain open. 

The Onion Tree Pizza Co. puts an Indian spin on classic Italian pizza, including their signature chicken tikka masala pizza.

Below is the closing announcement from Instagram yesterday. (H/T Salim!)

6 comments:

dwg said...

With another pizza joint just down the block it seemed one of them was not going to make it.

ed anger said...

that’s too bad, their food was good and pretty unique.

David Jennings said...

Getting harder and harder to sustain a business in NYC, especially EV. Unless you go viral on social media, you're going to struggle. Sad times.

Sheila Reveala said...

Pizza shops all around that immediate area, and as soon as one closes, another one opens.

Sheila Reveala said...

They were relying on their different approach to make a difference. Unfortunately, they presented as a sit-down place, rather than grab-and-go--an impediment for drunk, high people. And with pizza--so many opt for what they already know. I regret not giving it a try, but everything I had a hankering for pizza, never once considered The Onion Tree (a lousy name for a pizza-forward place)

Wildflower said...

Yo why you hating on the onion tree so much Sheila?