Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Village View parking lot sale moves forward as shareholders raise financial questions

EVG file photos by Stacie Joy

The proposed sale of a parking lot at Village View is moving into another phase, even as some shareholders continue to question the co-op's finances and the process surrounding a potential deal. 

At an Oct. 20 Zoom meeting of the Village View board of directors, board president Christine Hadlow announced that the board had accepted bids from two developers, according to a report from the resident-run VillageViewCommunity.com. 

The developers are now expected to begin due diligence, which typically involves inspecting the property and reviewing financial and other information before a possible transaction. 

The property in question is Parking Lot 7, on Second Street between Avenue A and First Avenue, part of the 1,236-unit Mitchell-Lama cooperative.
As EVG reported in June, the board voted in January to hire Alan Cohen of ABS Partners to market the lot to prospective residential developers. 

The possibility of a sale has generated differing opinions among shareholders. Some see an opportunity to generate revenue for the aging cooperative and help pay for future capital improvements. Others have questioned the decision-making process, the potential loss of parking and whether any new development would include affordable housing. 

More recently, some residents have sought additional financial records to better understand a reported $15.7 million decline in Village View's reserve fund. The resident-run website says a Manhattan Supreme Court proceeding seeking access to the co-op's books and records remains unresolved. The decline has become a point of contention among shareholders, although the information provided does not establish what accounted for the change in reserves. 

The latest developments come ahead of Village View's board election, scheduled for Nov. 11, when five seats are to be filled. A candidates' night was scheduled for last night (Monday), allowing residents to hear from those seeking seats on the board. 

Meanwhile, management distributed a notice on Oct. 23 titled "Protect Your Shareholder Voting Rights," encouraging residents to report any intimidation or threatening behavior related to the election. 

The notice has prompted questions from some residents about why it was distributed. No specific incidents or election irregularities were identified in the information provided to EVG.

For now, the potential sale remains under consideration, with questions about the property's future, the co-op's financial needs and shareholder participation still to be resolved.

27 comments:

Anonymous said...

More housing is such a positive especially in a parking lot!

ed anger said...

put in a parking garage, convert the lots to housing

Anonymous said...

They should demand affordable housing and a parking garage. Do a tall parking garage and charge for it and use that money to pay down some debt. Don't do luxury housing. That's just going to further squash the neighborhood.

Anonymous said...

Convert NYCHA parking lots to housing

Anonymous said...

I've lived at Village View for 50 years so I know from which I speak. Village View is a Mitchel Lama development which is overseen by HPD. The potential sale of this parking lot wouldn't be possible without HPD's expressed approval. Anyone who lives in V.V. knows that our buildings are slowing crumbling from lack of adequate funding. HPD supports this sale because they know this truth as well. The allegations of fiscal mis-management or outright theft would have already been discovered by the numerous oversight agencies which have already conducted investigations like the D.A.'s office, Dept. of Investigations, all local elected officials and the Mayor's office which have all been contacted.
V.V. operates solely on the "rent" that cooperators pay. As an "affordable" housing development with 50% Senior population on fixed income, this collection DOES NOT cover the ever increasing yearly operating maintenance costs. NO ONE is coming to bail out V.V. The sale of this parking lot will create a financial endowment that will allow V.V. to remain affordable for middle class families for generations to come. The only other option is to continue to increase the "rent"/maintenance year over year till V.V. can no longer consider itself affordable. There is only two options, sell the lot and save our community for years to come or increase the rent till mostly seniors are evicted for failing to pay their ever increasing rent bill. The choice is simple. I know what I will chose.

Anonymous said...

October 27, 2026 at 11:07 AM is spot on.

- Fellow VV Resident

Anonymous said...

There is a middle ground if the residents of VV believe they need additional revenue to keep the buildings financially viable which is to develop affordable housing on the site. There are affordable housing developers throughout the City and in our neighborhood who would love to purchase this site. They would get developers fees for building the 100 percent affordable units. They would need to set aside 15% of the units for unhoused people, singles or families,1 of every 4 children in the NYC school system is homeless BTW. VV would get their cash infusion, the neighborhood would get much needed affordable housing, some of our unhoused neighbors would get a home and a developer would get a tidy sum in the form of developers fees. That would require a bit more effort on the part of VV, but would be a win, win. A sale to the highest bidder for lux condos or rentals sounds more like the we got ours and that's all we are concerned with.

Scuba Diva said...

Luxury housing subsidizes the few "affordable" units.

Anonymous said...

What is the plan for people who currently have parking spots in that lot?

Anonymous said...

Although I feel for those that might potentially lose their parking spot, I am more concerned with the overall financial solvency of V.V. to continue to be a lone island of affordability for middle class families in a sea of market rate condo developments springing up around us.

Anonymous said...

Please do me a favor and contact any major and established real estate attorney and or large real estate property development firm in NYC who has documentable proof of working with HPD and ask them to evaluate your middle ground proposal as to its feasibility. Once you do, and get an answer, please do publish here. I would like to hear what the results are...

Anonymous said...

Part of the offer is any new proposal needs to provide parking to offset was was lost on the lot.

Anonymous said...

For one, rent stabilized apartments should have a time limit. I think the original intent was to get people on their feet in their early years and then be a productive part of society. “Affordable Housing” is not free. It is paid for via Federal, state and city allowances, i.e. us hardworking folks’ taxes. They are not kidding when they say it’s a lottery because it is literally winning the lottery. Why should working class people have to support those too lazy to work ? Granted, some people are elderly, physically or mentally disabled but there is such a sense of entitlement in the city. In the East Village specifically, because someone at sometime told them once at a party that they were interesting and they feel that they made the neighborhood what it is today.

Anonymous said...

I think that everyone should have affordable housing, healthcare and all the basics. Then if you want more go for it. Human Rights.

Anonymous said...

You are (quite ignorantly) confusing Rent Stabilization, which is not subsidized by anyone, with Public Housing, which is.

Anonymous said...

do you honestly believe that every single person living in this co-op (which you must buy by the way in addition to paying a monthly maintenance fee) doesn't work and that their rent is somehow coming out of your pocket? please be serious.

Anonymous said...

The attitude seems to be that the people living in rent stabilized apartments don't work. That is incorrect. We have people who make $70,000 a year who live in rent stabilized apartments. That has been part of the deal with 80/20

Anonymous said...

It quite literally is effectively subsidized by not being at market rate.

Anonymous said...

Reserves went down from $17 Million to next to nothing in several years. The proposed sale will allow VV to pocket $30-35 Million (per board) in best case scenario.
VV will be at square 1 shortly after the sale at current spending rates. There has to be a more sustainable solution. The only way to know if there was no mismanagement of funds is to do a forensic audit. Coop means corporation and needs to be treated as such.

Anonymous said...

All 7 buildings with over 1200 units need to be gut renovated. $40 million that they are hopping to get from this sale is a drop in the bucket. The Entire Heating system including All the radiators need to be replaced. Many doors, window. These buildings may be obsolete sooner than we think. Financial audit is a great idea, but they also need an engineering team to do a full audit. Some similar age buildings are already looking into being replaced.

Anonymous said...

There is a recent example of a private developer purchasing property from the Catholic Church on East 12th street, where they partnered with two local not for profits to develop 100 percent affordable housing with a set aside for homeless people. HPD is financing the construction.

Anonymous said...

I live there. The buildings don't necessarily need "gut renovations." But the plumbing is the biggest issue right now as it's approaching 63 years of age. And right alongside it, the elevators, which break down frequently. The interiors of the elevators were rehabbed some years ago, but functionally the elevators need replacement (motors, cable systems, etc).

Windows were replaced in 2005 and are still in fine shape. Facades and balconies were repaired approx 4-5 years ago per Local Law 11, and roof replacements continue. Other issues have been managed over the years, including boiler replacements and water valve replacements.

Anonymous said...

Agreed, forensic audit necessary. to clarify management of funds.

Anonymous said...

Full audit is a great idea. Let’s get some clarity here.

Anonymous said...

What a bunch of crybabies on this site. If you can’t afford to live here, then you should further your education, take up a trade or work more hours. You shouldn’t expect everyone else to subsidize you. One of the comments mentioned that they have to purchase their apartments. I know someone that got in about 10 years ago and I believe they paid $35,000. That’s about 95% below market rate.

Anonymous said...

Seriously there’s no need for name calling. VV is a Mitchell Lama housing coop. It is not market rate, and never was meant to be market rate. They are a development for middle income people. I think they have a right to ask for an audit. If there’s nothing to hide, there’s nothing to fear PERIOD.

Anonymous said...

For new construction, some costs are offset by tax credits. For older buildings…? Are you under the impression the city cuts those landlords a yearly check? Rent stabilization is a check on landlord profiteering. But then you’re obviously some sort of jerk would-be finance bro, so naturally you’d mind it.