Friday, April 17, 2026

[UPDATED] For-lease sign arrives at longtime home of Two Boots Pizza on Avenue A — surprising owner, staff

Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy 

For-lease signs went up today outside Two Boots Pizza on Avenue A and Third Street — catching owner Phil Hartman and staff by surprise.

Hartman said they did not see the sign being installed. 

The timing is less than ideal: Hartman is hosting a private after-party at the pizzeria tonight tied to long-awaited screenings of his 1986 film "No Picnic" opening at the Film Forum.

As previously reported, the longtime home of Two Boots — at 42 Avenue A — was recently listed for rent for the first time in decades amid ongoing lease negotiations. 

Hartman has said he's "cautiously optimistic" about staying in the space, though the listing — and now the arrival of signage — adds a new layer of urgency to the situation. 

Two Boots has been on Avenue A since the 1980s. Hartman previously told us he'd find a home elsewhere in the East Village if necessary. He has no plans to leave the neighborhood he loves. 

Whatever comes next, tonight belongs to Hartman.

Updated 4:18 p.m. 

A tipster told us the sign has been removed... and we confirmed.

While Hartman said he had a cordial relationship with the landlord, he was upset when he learned the for-lease banner had been put up without his knowledge. 

"I will get them to take it down," he told us.
Previously on EV Grieve

8 comments:

Shadowwhispers said...

Well that just sucks.

Anonymous said...

would really be terrible to lose Two Boots--they are part of fabric of community. Someone should start petition to landlord

Exterminator said...

Put up a different sign, ‘Landlord for sale’

Anonymous said...

Holy Fuck! And they put the 'For Lease' sign right on top of the active operating business' sign?! Yah, that is 'cordial'.

Anonymous said...

100%!! Holy fuck exactly!! Nothing like a landlord who fixates on their greed and grows to loathe the neighborhood that made them possible. Phil and so many others before and after are why this glorious neighborhood and that building is worth anything to said landlord. Nothing is more pathetic than being on top, hosting a legacy nyc pizza spot, hardly a landlord in the city can say that, YET, just the thought of some more cash tosses those facts in the literal river. Greedy fools like this need to go do this where it's in fashion, Austin or Florida or whatever.

Anonymous said...

move in to the old Gruppo spot!

Anonymous said...

Yessssss

Anonymous said...

Not a bad idea, but is that landlord any better?