Photos and reporting by Stacie Joy
We may have seen the last of a great East Village bar, the time capsule that is Lucy's (aka Blanche's Lucy's Tavern), at 135 Avenue A. (Updated Feb. 5
here.)
In late November (our story
here), the Department of Health temporarily closed the decades-spanning bar between St. Mark's Place and Ninth Street. According to DOH records: "Food Protection Certificate (FPC) not held by manager or supervisor of food operations."
Longtime proprietor Ludwika "Lucy" Mickevicius said at the time that she thought her bookkeeper had paid the previous fine and had the proper paperwork on file. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case.
In addition, the bar's liquor license expired at the end of November.
In a phone call on Saturday, Lucy said that she had the liquor license, though there is a much bigger problem — she has no lease.
The two buildings at 135-137 Avenue A recently
sold for $19.1 million.
Lucy had been on a month-to-month lease with the previous landlord, with whom she enjoyed a good business relationship.
The new owner — an LLC with a Brooklyn address — now wants $25,000 a month in rent.
Lucy reports she is in talks with the new landlord but cannot afford to pay the increased rent.
She isn't overwhelmingly optimistic and says the bar may be forced to close permanently.
And in an ominous development, someone blacked out the hand-painted Lucy's sign above the entrance (
see top photo). Last fall, someone crossed out the name with a red paint line, though that was mostly seen as shenanigans/vandalism.
As for her sign, Lucy didn't have any answers. "We talking, you know, it's New York; what can you do?"
We agreed to talk again in a few days or a week and see if there are any developments and hopes of setting foot in this bar again for a drink and game of pool.