Wednesday, January 31, 2024

That penthouse with a cottage atop 1st Street and 1st Avenue is ... back... on... the... market!

Image via DroneHub Media 

The penthouse unit at 72 E. First St. — aka The Minthorne House — at First Avenue with the Cape Cod-style cottage on its rooftop is BACK on the market. 

One of the most unique East Village homes sold in the summer of 2017 for $3.5 million. Now the circa-1841 space with 5 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms spread out over two floors has a $9.75 million ask, this after renovations. (Find the listing here.) 

Per the listing (which Curbed first noted): 
The crown of the penthouse is the Cape Cod-style roof cottage and private landscaped terrace, one of New York City’s most delectable hidden gems. With ceilings up to 12', exposures on three sides, an open view to the south, and a level of finish equal to the rest of the house, the cottage is a transportative oasis. 

As a standalone studio, it can function as a guest suite or a private home office. A banquette with bay windows overlooks the planted terrace, with shrubbery, an apple tree, and multiple seating and lounging areas.

You can find more photos and descriptive descriptions right here.  

Until 2017, Gale Barrett Shrady was reportedly the owner. The cottage addition was the handiwork of her late husband, artist Henry Merwin Shrady III. She called the charming cottage a "magical little spot" that served as her son's bedroom through college.

P.S.

Bring back Boca Chica!

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

I hope someone buys it, then puts it on the market for $30 million in two years 🙄

Bobby G said...

When he first built it, Henry took me up to his "Cape Cod Cottage" clad in cedar shingles. He called it "Upuponit," a nod to the South Fork more than Cape Cod. It has little windows with 360 degree views.

Henry also told me that back in the 1820s his ancestors had a farm where Allen Street is now. He came from an old New York family.

Anonymous said...

If only I could win the NY Lottery. Manifesting this now.

XTC said...

Pretty stunning residence even for NY, but pretty rare for he EV. Except for the lame artwork it's very nicely designed and styled. Loved the colored tile bathrooms, original wood on the the window frames, and funky but no too crazy kitchen. The French campaign chair in the bedroom with the leather straps is killing me. I passed on buying a similar one last month. Lovely landscaping with the yellow maples on the terrace.

Carol from East 5th Street said...

At $9.75 million I hope it's an elevator building.

Anonymous said...

ooooh. the penthouse is kinda cute, but lacks enough closet space.

Anonymous said...

Stunning. I would be such a shut-in with a place like that.

Grieve said...

@ Carol,

There is an elevator!

Anonymous said...

I love everything about it except the price, LOL.

marjorie said...

GAAAAAH what a great renovation. I am envious! I hate this feeling! I prefer to revel in my snotty superior snark about the finance dipsticks with endless money turning quirky apartments into soulless white minimalist boxes! Seriously, it's stunning.

Anonymous said...

Proud to say I work for the architect and am loyal supporter of EVG!

Anonymous said...

Nexus of the universe!