I haven't tried this pizza yet... A reader passed along his or her experience:
A guy who works very hard selling a $4 slice in a neighborhood that buys $1 slices and $2 Falafel complains to another worker about how hard he works to sell the pizza and it isn't even his place. While the cheese is good (although a little too subtle), and the crust thin and crisp, the flavor is underwhelming. The first-class ingredients could use a little kick-up. I don't plan to spend $4 there again.
Previously on EV Grieve:
Rumors!: Will PJ Hanley's be opening a pizza shop on First Avenue?
A Stop Work Order for the P.J. Hanley's pizza parlor on First Avenue